Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Who Wore It Better - The Dianna Agron Edition

Dianna Agron is best known for her portrayal as 'Quinn Fabray' on the popular TV series 'Glee', however, she is quickly gaining fame as a fashion icon in Young Hollywood too. The 26 year old actress faces off in three different looks on this edition of 'Who Wore It Better'. She picks out lovely feminine frocks that either inspires the style of other starlets or which just happen to be carbon copy coincidence. You decide...

Round One - Stella McCartney
Dianna was the first to wear this elegant black velour-front peplum dress by Stella McCartney back in August 2011. The dress is an impeccable fit on Dianna, this look seems to be made for her. She styled it with cropped waves, YSL Tribtoo pumps and red lipstick.
Next is It-Girl Miroslava Duma, who wore the chic fitted dress to a Glamour Event, along with sleek straight hair, a Bottega Veneta clutch bag & nude Christian Louboutin 'Pigalle' pumps.
Kim Kardashian was spotted out in NYC in the same dress almost a year later than Dianna. Kim added gold cuffs and a trendy pair of Christian Louboutin 'Bis Un Bout' PVC and patent pumps. When compared to the other two, this dress doesn't seem the best silhouette for her.

The Verdict: It's a difficult choice between Miroslava and Dianna, as they both looked exceptional in this Stella McCartney dress, but my vote goes to Dianna, it's just the perfect fit.


Round Two - Alice + Olivia
Dianna was the first to wear this Alice + Olivia golden sunflower print dress with box-pleat skirt in April this year, while in New York City. She kept warm with a woolen coat and stepped out in navy blue 'Cosmic' pumps by Jimmy Choo.
We recently saw Holland Roden wear the exact same dress at the last month's Teen Choice Awards (July 2012). The Teen Wolf actress looked pretty, pairing her version with a skinny metallic belt, gold Lauren Merkin clutch and nude 'Pigalle' pumps by Christian Louboutin.
Just a week later, jazz singer and actress Renee Olstead wore the sunflower dress to a Nylon event in LA. Renee picked a pair of Fendi platform pumps to complete her look, and an animal print bandana scarf that leaves much to be desired.

The Verdict: Holland Roden wins this round hands down, her styling was complimentary to the dress and she somehow gave it girlier appeal.


Round Three - Tracy Reese for Anthropologie


Dianna was eye-catching in a Tracy Reese for Anthropologie 'Impressionist' dress, which she wore in June 2012. The pretty silk-linen digital print dress was paired with a black and silver belt, Coach legacy leather bag, glittery Miu Miu heels and snazzy turquoise sunnies.
Talk about Déja vu - just one day before Dianna wore the dress, Disney actress Caroline Sunshine wore it to the LA Film Festival on 18 June 2012. The 'Shake It Up' star carried a bright pink clutch to match her pink dip-dyed hair and walked in nude pointy toe heels.
Oprah's right-hand Gayle King picked out this seemingly youthful dress with grassy print hemline for a CBS event last month on 29 July. She invigorated her look with lime green Manolo Blahnik sandals. I find this look too young on her.

The Verdict: I'm really not taking sides, but I have to give this final round to Dianna, she took an edgy risk with the accessories and it paid off. 


I would love to hear your thoughts on each look. If you'd like, in the comment box, type in Round 1 to 3 and next to it, let me know who you think wore each dress best.


63 comments:

Bodil Huisman said...

I love her the most in the Tracy Reese dress, printed dresses look great on Dianna! Great selection Sam! :)

Love,
Bo

Elly @ Caribbean Living said...

I think I'm going to have to vote: Diana, Diana, Caroline (love the pink clutch).

Love all three looks, especially the sunflowers dress, just gorgeous!

she.is.the.one said...

the black peplum is icredibile!!!
http://she-is-the-1.blogspot.ch/

Daniella said...

Aw Sam great post, I always love to see how different people have worn one particular piece. Okay so my verdicts are.... Round one-has to be Miroslava Duma, Round two - I like how Dianna added in the coat but as an overall it would be Holland Roden and for Round three I think it's safe to say that Dianna takes the win!! :)

Take care, Daniella xox

Dominika said...

Round 1: It was pretty hard for me to choose between Kim and Dianna. On the one hand, I believe it fits Dianna perfectly, like you said- it seems to be made for her! On the other, I can't get enough of Kim's curves and I love how she flaunts them instead of hiding under baggy clothes. My vote goes to Dianna though.
Round 2: Definitely Holland Roden, I love how she paired it with that belt, it's really figure-flattering in her case!
Round 3: Dianna, an amazing choice of accessories, she totally rocked that outfit!

http://glamourxkills.blogspot.com

Nicoleta_B said...

Hi love! Awesome selection!!!

Thank u so much for you lovely comment on my blog! Gladly follow you via Bloglovin and GFC. I would appreciate if u could follow me via GFC too.

Kisses,

www.nicoleta.me

New post is up! Hight Low Obesession!

Fictitious Fashion said...

yes holland rocks the outfit bt in the last dress caroline looks stunning too! :D


Thank you for your lovely comment on my earlier post:)

Maybe you have time see my New post- G for Giveaway: Prodigy red

An Awesome giveaway on my blog, by Prodigy Red~ Win a sexy jersey dress ENTER HERE

Love
Akanksha

Thesmallnoble said...

I love the second dress! I think Holland Roden wore it best! :)

http://thesmallnoble.blogspot.de/

Zoe Concepción said...

Well, My favourtie dress it's the first one and for me the girl who wore it better is Dianna Agron. Love it with a pair of black shoes and no complements!!!!!!
Have a great day Sam! Check out my new loafers!
xoxo

Cinnamon and White Chocolate said...

It's amazing how much better these dresses look with a belt (round 2, photo 2 and round 3, photo 1)

Katie Frank said...

first black mix is the best <3
http://coeursdefoxes.blogspot.com/
http://www.facebook.com/CoeursDeFoxes

Lilli said...

Hi Sam! totally love the first peplum dress, is just gorgeous! They 3 wore it very well! I want it!!!:) Kisses dear and have a nice day!:*

A Daft Scots Lass said...

Dianna rocked #1
Holland won round #2 (the skinny belt and nude heels - a nice touch)
Dianna nailed #3 (love that matching sunnies)

I ♥ Stella McCartney

ftashion said...

First of all the dresses are really gorgeous! I think Miroslava nailed dress 1. Holland for dress 2 and Dianna for dress 3! it's interesting that some dresses just seemed to be made for some people!

Fang Ting
ftashion

Miška said...

I think every single woman looks beautiful in her own way :)

Tammy Lau said...

hah..I always like how you ask us who wear the best..I love Miroslava Duma, i think its because of the shoes!!!

EDGYMIX New Post-Antarctica Natural Beauty

Hanna & Christel said...

aewsome post!

1. Dianna
2. Holland
3. Caroline

:)

<3

Jelena Dimić said...

I adore that black peplum dress! I wish I could have it! *.*
I'm following you now. :D If you want, you can find me on: http://the-wandering-heart.blogspot.com
Lots of love! :*

Collections said...

She has a great collection of dresses!

Collections

Teresa said...

Round 1 - I prefer Miroslava. She looks so chic and peplum suits her so well! Plus the beige shoes gave a different color to the whole outfit<3

Round 2 - Holland looks adorable & perfect, but I prefer Dianna because she took some risk with blue shoes and a coat and didn't failed!

Round 3 - Dianna styled this dress and made it her own!!!!

Love,
Teresa
www.trend-ish.com

Adeola Naomi said...

The black peplum dress is just magnificent!
I also like round two, picture two.
The print dress definitely look great on Diana with all the accessories she paired it with.

Xixia said...

Ooh...I think I have to agree with you on all your choices. In Round 1, Diana just has this perfect hollywood glamour look going on that suits the peplum dress perfectly.
That Alice + Olivia dress is too sweet and sunny to be covered up by a black jacket, I think, and Hollend gives it that charming appeal. And for the last round, I think those turquoise rimmed sunglasses won it for me. :)

♥ x i x i a | thisisxixia.com

Alessandra said...

Loving the first pic!!!

http://lapetiterobenoire-ale.blogspot.com
https://www.facebook.com/lapetiterobenoire.ale

Shahrzād said...

Diane/Hollande/Caroline!

I need your help! can you watch my video on my blog!

http://leguidedelama.blogspot.com

XxxLoveIsBeautyxxX said...

love the black peplum dress! followed you, hope you can follow back! http://xxxloveisbeautyxxx.blogspot.ie/

Denise said...

Round 1: Dianna, although somehow I didn't dislike it worn by KK;
Round 2: Holland Roden - that is my favorite style for dresses/skirts, and I always prefer when it's worn with a belt!
Round 3: Dianna, again, because of the belt, as I said before!
Mmm... went to the eye doctor yesterday, she insisted to see me again. Will go to another one for a second opinion. News were not sooo nad, but also not sooo good. Will write you this week! Don't worry - as I said, not bad at all, just also not good at all!

Jessica said...

yes i really love her style! i pretty much agree spot on with your take on all three :D

-Jessica
http://www.jumpintopuddles.com

Stephanie said...

Holland Roden is such a cutie!

http://fashionroll.net

Margaret Cruzemark said...

Miroslava wore the first dress better. I so much hate Kim Kardashian!!!
Best Regards
Miss Margaret Cruzemark
http://margaretcruzemark.blogspot.gr/

Cathy said...

My picks:
Round 1: Dianna
Round 2: Holland
Round 3: Dianna

Fun post, Sam!

http://cstyledesign.blogspot.com

Carolyna said...

love the black dress

Marie said...

Nice blog and post
glad to find it!!
follow each other from gfc?
oxoxoxo

Marie
http://iintothegroove.blogspot.com/

Wil Harris said...

My picks:
1. Dianna
2. Holland
3. Dianna

It seems that we have the same taste! ;)
A fun and great post, love it.

Marie Martell said...

Hey Sam!! Hope all is well :) Here are my thoughts on these really great looks.

Round 1. Kim K's curves and shoes did it for me! I also like the "edgy feel" to this look.
Round 2. Holland Roden looks super feminine and pretty. Her hair, lenght of dress, shoes and belt are perfect.
Round 3. Dianna totally from head to toe rocked this dress! Love the glasses and belt.

Have a great day darling! xo Marie
http://nyorkeratheart.blogspot.com

Well... said...

Man, this girl can definitely dress well! I agree with all your verdicts haha.
I'm gonna have to keep an eye on Diana's style...I really like it ;)

Enter to win a gift certificate to Rire Boutique!
Trendy Teal

Vivi Vintageová said...

Oh, this is great post!
1. Dianna, 2. Holland Roden, 3. Dianna ;-)
Kisses..
www.vintageblog.cz;

Jodie said...

thanks for commenting on my blog- i think you hit the nail on the head here. i agree with everyything! and i really want that black velour number
x
www.be-a-goddess.blogspot.co.uk

Jayme and Mendi said...

I agree with your picks!! Funny too because I just got my latest issue of US magazine and the impressionist dress was featured with the above ladies and I thought to myself how not pretty this dress is. :-)

Jayme @ Her Late Night Cravings

Diana S.T. said...

thanks for your comment, I love preppy outfits too... your post is great, I like the way you write... =)

Tie Bow-tie said...

i love all these dresses! But Kim's wearing the most gorgeous dress)

Helena Resende said...

Once again I agree with you! :)

diana said...

Such a lovely post, I love your blog¡¡
Take a look and if you want we can follow each others: http://loscaprichosdediana.blogspot.com.es/

xoxo

Confessions of A Confused City Girl said...

I think I have to agree with you on this one!

~Sherine
Stop by and say HI!
Confessions Of A City Girl 

MOSAMUSE said...

Diana for the gold!
xo
MOSAMUSE

www.MOSAMUSE.com

Paris said...

I agree with you, especially for Round Two! Holland really makes the dress so much better with the waist-cinching metallic gold belt!
Thanks for your sweet wishes (as always) on my post for today as well! :)

xoxo,
Paris

glitteratiandglamour.blogspot.com

Kim (A Very Sweet Blog) said...

Round 1 - Kim Kardashian Rock's It!
Round 2 - Holland Roden Looks Sweet
Round 3 - Caroline Sunshine Looks Adorable

http://www.averysweetblog.com/

Popcorn, Pugs & Peonies said...

Round 1 Dianna
Round 2 Holland
ROund 3 Dianna all the way

*Erin

Punctuation Mark said...

Definitely Diana does it better... Ha! Kim has to understand her body is not for every style

Fashion.MakeUp.LifeStyle said...

Round 1 Kim, Round 2 Holland, Round 3 Diana.


<3 Marina
Fashion.MakeUp.LifeStyle

bridechic said...

1 Never thought I give a Kardasian 1st prize in anything but here she takes the cake
2 Diana
3 Diana

Rahul Bhatia said...

Kim Kardasian still still hogs the limelight:)

Ember Drake said...

For me it's definitely:

1. Miroslava Duma
2. Holland Roden
3. Dianna

The Tracy Reese for Anthropologie dress is my favourite of the bunch and I think Dianna really nails this look!

Em
x

http://emberdrake.blogspot.co.uk

Cindy C. said...

Definitely 1-duna 2-raden 3-agron (:

xoxo,
Cindy C.
http://styleologie.blogspot.com/

Ann said...

Round 1 - Diana
Round 2 - Holland
Round 3 - Caroline.

Gorgeous outfits ♥

Nicoleta_B said...

Hi love! Thank you so much for following me.

Loooooots of kisses,

www.nicoleta.me

Nicole said...

Dianna looks the best in all three outfits! :)

Anna said...

diana, holland, caroline

(:


xAnna
fairytalefrocks.blogspot.com

ps. join my GIVEAWAY to catch a little ray of moonlight.
http://fairytalefrocks.blogspot.nl/2012/08/moonlight-in-vail-giveaway.html

The Chic Sheet said...

OMG!!! Mira! Mira! She killed it in peplum :) LOVE.


XX,
Miranda

Kate Frenkel said...

I don't like dresses from the round#2 and #3. The first dress is amazing and Miroslava wears it best. It's not patriotic :-), she really looks stunning in this dress!!!

Rikki said...

I agree with on this!
round 1 Diana for sure! as you said its the perfect fit!
round 2 Holland Roden
round 3 Diana again, though caroline sunshine carries it off well too!

Have a great weekend<3

Jeanae' said...

Dianna wins all! I love her confidence!

Elle Sees said...

Diana loving the black

Fashion-Bridge said...

I have a major girl's crush on Miroslava. So I vote for her:) She's utterly stylish!

Xx

Alexandra

www.fashion-bridge.blogspot.com